 |
|
Review
By:
Greg Lynch |
|
Developer: |
Midway |
|
Publisher: |
Midway |
|
# of Players: |
1-4 |
|
Genre: |
Compilation |
| ESRB: |
Teen |
|
Online: |
Yes (Leaderboards) |
|
Accessories: |
N/A |
|
Date Posted: |
3-9-04 |
In the gaming
world, nothing seems to sell quite as well as nostalgia. One need
only look at how much people are charging for classic games on Ebay
to know there’s a huge amount of money to be made. Everyone wants to
remember those days of hanging out at the roller skating rink and
playing Donkey Kong, right?

It
didn’t take long for software companies to catch on to this concept
and start releasing all those retro memories on modern consoles.
However, while those games bring back old memories for many of us,
we tend to forget they typically aren’t as fun as our trip down
memory lane leads us to believe. A quick play of many classics
reveal that, despite all those fond memories of the golden age of
videogames, we’ve started to expect more from our games.
Enter
Midway Arcade Treasures, a huge collection of games spanning the
entire length of what many consider to be the classic era of gaming,
and it is perhaps the best example of how some classics never grow
old. From the earlier games such as Joust, to the later
releases like Smash T.V., this is arguably the best
collection of games assembled into one package. The list of those
included practically reads like a “Best Of” from the 80’s:
-
720°
-
Blaster
-
Bubbles
-
Defender
-
Defender II
-
Gauntlet
-
Joust
-
Joust 2
-
Klax
-
Marble Madness
-
Paperboy
-
Rampage
-
Rampart
-
RoadBlasters
-
Robotron 2084
-
Root Beer Tapper
-
Satan's Hollow
-
Smash TV
-
Sinistar
-
Splat!
-
Spy Hunter
-
Super Sprint
-
Toobin'
-
Vindicators
While Xbox owners are treated to perfect emulation on
each title (the PlayStation 2 version features a hint of slowdown in
the more modern games, such as Smash TV), the controls are
another matter. Anyone who played the games in their original form
will remember some of the titles using special controllers that were
all but mandatory for smooth gameplay. Super Sprint and
Spy Hunter used a steering wheel and accelerator, Marble
Madness used a trackball to simulate rolling the marble, and
720°
had a joystick locked into a circular-only motion, just to name a
few. The same innovation used by Midway to set their games apart
from everyone else ends up hurting a few titles in this collection.
Most control issues just take some minor adjusting, or the
acceptance that you might not do as well in a game as you did in the
old days. Playing games like Toobin’ requires an adjustment
period, as does Vindicators. Rampart is the only real
exception, taking a huge hit in fun because of a horribly
unresponsive controller. Originally played using a trackball, the
joystick and buttons are just no substitute. When rebuilding your
castle walls, the Tetris-like piece will either not move, or move
twice as many spaces than you wanted it to, which can become really
frustrating when you have only a few precious seconds to completely
surround your castle. You’ll likely lose more games to this fault
than any lack of skill. It’s a shame, since the game is arguably one
of the best on the package, and the problem could easily have been
avoided by utilizing analog controls over digital.

Several
bonuses are included, but feel as though they were thrown in. In
fact, the movies are nothing more than ported over from the
Playstation versions of other Midway compilations, grainy video and
all. Other options include Trivia, Galleries, and History, and
probably will only be of interest to old school gamers or
collectors. Regardless, not all games include those options, and
finding the ones that do can take some patience thanks to bizarre
menu screens and having to go through each game option independently
looking for them. It was a nice gesture on behalf of Midway, but
could just as easily have been left out with little consequence.
What really
separates the Xbox version from all others is the inclusion of Live
leaderboards, and the enormous impact it makes on the game’s
longevity. While the games stand great on their own and besting your
own high score is a lot of fun, nothing compares to trying to topple
other player’s high scores. It adds a feeling of competition to the
game that actually keeps drawing you in with the desire to reach
that number one spot. Fortunately, while the game has numerous
options for lives, continues, and skill levels, to post on the
leader board you must choose the leaderboard settings so everyone is
on the same playing field.
Highs:
-
Online
leaderboards
-
Perfect
emulation
-
20 (!) classic
games
Lows:
-
Poor control
in a few games
Final
Verdict:
Despite a few
of the title’s shortcomings, this collection is far and away the
best compilation I’ve ever spent time with. Between the perfectly
emulated games and the addition of Live functionality, it elevates
itself above the competition by becoming a collection you will
return to over and over. Nearly every game in the package is a
classic, and you’ll likely find yourself playing it long after the
rest of your compilations are collecting dust. For the old school
gamer, this title is a must. For the younger gamer, it’s the one
collection that will help convince you that the old-timers might not
be lying about the “good old days”.
Overall
Score:
8.5
Additional
Images:
|
|
 |